Panico`s in West Cape May

Amazing dinner they are doing amazing during a difficult time!

Amazing food! With even better service. Cassie made our dining during COVID so enjoyable :)

One of our favorite restaurants in Cape May. BYOB is appreciated. Excellent menu, delicious entres, reasonable prices. Does not take reservations but somehow you can call and get on a short list. They had Xmas lites on windows and we all thought they should keep them up all year round. Very attractive.

Great food, a little off the beaten path but well worth it. Outside dining available. Try the grilled octopus as an appetizer. Jordan was a great server.

Amazing place! Just got back and were blown away by the quality of food and politeness of our waiter Dwane. We there as a large group of people, adults and kids, and had to wait but it was so worth it. The prices were very reasonable for such quality.

The food is authentic Italian food and absolutely delicious. The handsome owner Steve and his lovely wife are involved in all the details. Steven makes the pizza. The place was an old church and has a parking lot. They also own Secondos. Try it you won't be disappointed

Loved the food and atmosphere. Wait staff is attentive and extremely friendly. Chef removed cheese from a pizza so that I was able to eat it. Panico's never disappoints!

This was amazing pizza; the service was great as well

Everything was excellent. The food, service and atmosphere was perfect.

Solid Italian restaurant. Great options also for kids

Been tough. Last time we came in we were not pleased. Just the quality was not up to a diner dining experience. I have been traveling, wanted just a salad and veg to try to get my eating habits back in order. Their GREEK salad has not lettuce. Apparently country salad is their version of no lettuce. Asparagus was fine. I am not a fan of raw peppers,onions and tomatoes with feta on top. :)

Was good, but I got bitten up by mosquitos terribly

Was limited to take out only because of Coronavirus. Best pizza I have ever had !! Shiitake mushrooms & telaggio cheese.

Excellent food and service despite COVID restrictions and a few sprinkles of rain.

It is an upscale place. Nice atmosphere. Good food. Wonderful bread and pizza. Did not have a main course so can not post an opinion

It doesn't have to be Sunday for a Grandmother's style Sunday dinner!!! This is a regular for us as their food is fabulous from the whole fish to the pizza and even the kids meals. Highly recommend to become a staple during your Cape May vacation.

Best itaiian I've had in Cape May, wow this place was delicious! The pork chop with ricotta gnocchi was out of this world and I am still dreaming about it. Very cool atmosphere aided by the airy church setting that you dine in. Our waiter was very good, knew the dishes, was funny and offered timely service. The whole experience notched the visit up to be one of the better dining experiences I've had in Cape May over 3 years of summer vacations. Would happily return!